Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

LEGAL ANALYSIS OF THE PRINCIPLE OF FREEDOM OF CONTRACT TOWARDS LEGAL CERTAINTY AND JUSTICE IN AN AGREEMENT Tumpal Haojahan Sihombing; Muh Amin Saleh; Muhenri Sihotang; Appe Hutauruk
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), June 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56371/jirpl.v7i3.701

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the implementation of the principle of freedom of contract in Indonesian positive law and its implications for legal certainty and justice for the parties in an agreement. The main focus of this study is directed at how to balance individual autonomy (party autonomy) with legal protection for parties with weaker bargaining power, especially in the use of standard contracts. The research method used is normative juridical with a statute approach and a conceptual approach. Data were collected through a literature study of primary legal materials such as the Civil Code and relevant secondary and tertiary legal materials. The results of the study indicate that the implementation of the principle of freedom of contract as regulated in Article 1338 paragraph (1) of the Civil Code has provided legal certainty through the principle of pacta sunt servanda. However, in practice, this legal certainty is often formalistic and tends to benefit parties who are economically and informationally dominant. Substantive justice is often neglected when freedom of contract is used as an instrument of exploitation through disproportionate exoneration clauses. This study concludes that freedom of contract is not absolute, but must be limited by the principles of good faith, propriety, and public order in order to create a balance of rights and obligations that is just for all parties.
EFFECTIVENESS OF CHILD PROTECTION IMPLEMENTATION IN HANDLING SEXUAL EXPLOITATION IN INDONESIA Muhammad Nasir; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), June 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56371/jirpl.v7i3.705

Abstract

Child sexual exploitation is a form of human rights violation that has serious impacts on children’s physical, mental, and social development. Although the government has enacted Law Number 35 of 2014 concerning Amendments to Law Number 23 of 2002 concerning Child Protection as the primary legal instrument for protecting children, the practice of child sexual exploitation continues to show alarming figures. This study uses a normative legal research method with a statute approach, a conceptual approach, and a case approach. The data used are primary legal materials, secondary legal materials, and tertiary legal materials obtained through literature studies. All legal materials are analyzed qualitatively using descriptive-analytical methods to obtain an overview of the conformity between legal provisions and their application in practice. The results of the study indicate that Law Number 35 of 2014 has regulated legal protection for child victims of sexual exploitation comprehensively through provisions regarding prevention, special protection, the imposition of criminal sanctions on perpetrators, and the restoration of victims’ rights. However, its implementation has not been running optimally because there are still various obstacles, including limited coordination between agencies, low capacity of law enforcement officers, lack of courage among victims to report, and minimal rehabilitation facilities and psychosocial support.
Understanding the Interplay Between Legal Morality, Corruption Penalization, and Public Patronage Culture: Evidence from a Systematic Literature Review Appe Hutauruk; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
Vifada Assumption Journal of Law Vol. 4 No. 1 (2026): January - June
Publisher : Yayasan Vifada Cendikia Indonesia

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.70184/2s3k9342

Abstract

Purpose: This study analyzes the ineffectiveness of normative-positivistic and repressive approaches to corruption eradication. It examines corruption's philosophical multidimensionalities, including justice concepts, and explains how power patronage, nepotism, and policy manipulation distort essential justice and undermine the welfare state. Research Design and Methodology: This study uses a normative research method combining a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) following PRISMA 2020 guidelines analyzing 87 articles with normative juridical analysis using statute, conceptual, and case approaches. Findings and Discussion: Corruption regularly destroys Aristotelian distributive and corrective justice and acts as the antithesis of John Rawls's just society by diverting resources to those with power. Corrupt public officials betray the legal system's internal morality, and Indonesia's entrenched patronage networks prioritize personal loyalty over formal bureaucracy, rendering current penalization ineffective at producing a deterrent effect. Implications: He study emphasizes the need for institutional reform to break patronage networks. It recommends treating corruption eradication not merely as a criminal law issue, but as an ethical project to build an anti-corruption state architecture pillared on accountability, transparency, and public integrity.
URGENSI PERUBAHAN PENGATURAN ORGANISASI ADVOKAT UNTUK MEWUJUDKAN FUNGSI HUKUM Robert L Simanungkalit; Appe Hutauruk; Mardiman Sane; Sunarno
Collegium Studiosum Journal Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Collegium Studiosum Journal
Publisher : LPPM STIH Awang Long

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56301/csj.v9i1.2356

Abstract

The enactment of the National Criminal Code under Law Number 1 of 2023 and the Criminal Procedure Code under Law Number 20 of 2025 marks a major reform of Indonesia's criminal justice system by reinforcing the position of advocates as equal law enforcement officers. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of these reforms is constrained by the fragmented structure of advocate organizations, which creates inconsistencies in professional standards, ethical enforcement, legal education, and institutional accountability. This study examines the urgency of reconstructing the regulation of advocate organizations to support the implementation of advocates' functions within the new criminal justice framework and proposes an institutional model that promotes professionalism, integrity, and legal certainty. The research applies a socio-legal approach with a dominant normative juridical method through library research, utilizing legislation, court decisions, books, and scientific journals as primary and secondary legal materials. The findings indicate that the current multi-bar system weakens professional standardization and ethical supervision, thereby reducing advocates' effectiveness in fulfilling their constitutional role. The study concludes that regulatory reconstruction is essential through an integrated institutional framework that standardizes professional education, strengthens ethical enforcement, and improves supervision while respecting the constitutional freedom of association. Such reform is expected to reinforce the advocate profession as an officium nobile and enhance justice, legal certainty, and the effectiveness of Indonesia's criminal justice system.
ANALISIS YURIDIS PELANGGARAN PRINSIP FIDUCIARY DUTY OLEH DIREKSI YANG MELAKUKAN RANGKAP JABATAN DALAM PERSEROAN TERBATAS Rumondang Sihite; Appe Hutauruk; Mardiman Sane; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaea
Collegium Studiosum Journal Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Collegium Studiosum Journal
Publisher : LPPM STIH Awang Long

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56301/csj.v9i1.2357

Abstract

The principle of fiduciary duty is an obligation that requires directors to manage the company in good faith, prudence, loyalty, and solely in the best interests of the company. In practice, directors who hold concurrent positions have the potential to create conflicts of interest that can reduce independence and increase the risk of violations of fiduciary obligations. This study aims to examine the legal regulations regarding the principle of fiduciary duty for directors who hold concurrent positions in limited liability companies and analyze the forms of fiduciary duty violations and their legal responsibilities based on Supreme Court Decision Number 1005 K/Pdt/2016. This study uses a normative legal research method. Legal materials are analyzed qualitatively through legal interpretation and legal reasoning. The results of the study indicate that in Supreme Court Decision Number 1005 K/Pdt/2016, the actions of directors who issue corporate guarantees without the approval of the Board of Commissioners are declared as a violation of the principle of fiduciary duty so that directors are held personally and jointly responsible for losses suffered by the company. This study concludes that it is necessary to strengthen legal regulations regarding fiduciary duty, clarify regulations regarding conflicts of interest due to dual positions, and implement the principles of good corporate governance more comprehensively to increase legal certainty, accountability in company management, and protection for shareholders and other stakeholders.
ANALISIS TERHADAP KESEIMBANGAN PERLINDUNGAN HAK CIPTA DAN KEPENTINGAN EKONOMI PELAKU USAHA DALAM PEMUNGUTAN ROYALTI MUSIK Indra Jaya; Appe Hutauruk; Mardiman Sane
Collegium Studiosum Journal Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Collegium Studiosum Journal
Publisher : LPPM STIH Awang Long

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56301/csj.v9i1.2358

Abstract

The enactment of Government Regulation Number 56 of 2021 concerning the Management of Copyright Royalties for Songs and/or Music represents a significant step toward strengthening the protection of the economic rights of creators and copyright holders in Indonesia. However, its implementation has raised legal issues regarding the determination of royalty-paying business actors, overlapping royalty obligations, and the balance between copyright protection and business interests in the digital era. This study aims to analyze the legal framework governing music royalty collection, evaluate whether the current system reflects the principles of justice, legal certainty, and proportionality, and formulate a fair limitation of royalty-paying subjects. The research employs a normative juridical method supported by a socio-legal approach through statutory, conceptual, comparative, case, and socio-legal analyses. The findings indicate that the existing regulatory framework does not clearly classify commercial music users, creating legal uncertainty and the potential imposition of disproportionate royalty obligations on businesses that use music only as a supporting element of their activities. Accordingly, this study proposes a reformulated royalty system that classifies users into Primary Users and Secondary Users based on the extent of direct economic benefit obtained from musical works. This approach is expected to promote a more balanced, equitable, and proportionate royalty management system while ensuring effective copyright protection and supporting sustainable business activities.
TINJAUAN HUKUM TINDAK PIDANA DUGAAN MAFIA TANAH OLEH APARATUR KECAMATAN SERPONG Ahsan Pasinringi; FX Suyud Margono; Appe Hutauruk
Collegium Studiosum Journal Vol. 9 No. 1 (2026): Collegium Studiosum Journal
Publisher : LPPM STIH Awang Long

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56301/csj.v9i1.2359

Abstract

Land mafia practices in Indonesia have become a systemic phenomenon that threatens legal certainty and human rights. The contradiction between the principle of the rule of law and the vulnerability of old land title documents (Girik/Letter C) often triggers maladministration and abuse of authority by officials at the village and sub-district levels. Ideally, land governance should guarantee the protection of community rights by adhering to the General Principles of Good Governance (AAUPB), particularly the principles of accuracy and legality. This normative juridical legal research analyzes the legal implications of government maladministration in issuing invalid land transfer letters and evaluates the role of the State Administrative Court (PTUN) as an instrument for rights restoration. Through a statutory approach and case studies, it was found that the actions of officials who failed to verify documents legally fulfilled the elements of an unlawful act by the government (onrechtmatige overheidsdaad). The results of the study indicate that the PTUN plays a crucial role as a corrective and repressive instrument for victims. As reflected in Decision Number 533K/TUN/KI/2019, the judiciary is capable of restoring the rights of legitimate owners in full (restitutio in integrum). As a solution, strengthening administrative order and accelerating the digitization of land documents at the village level is necessary. This step is urgently needed to close the vulnerabilities exploited by land mafia networks to ensure legal certainty for the community.
Reconstructing Standards for the Assessment of Electronic Evidence in Indonesian Civil Procedure from the Perspective of ISO/IEC 27037:2012 Appe Hutauruk; Adalin Ali; Hotman Sinambela
Politica: Jurnal Hukum Tata Negara dan Politik Islam Vol. 13 No. 1 (2026): Politica: Jurnal Hukum Tata Negara dan Politik Islam
Publisher : Prodi Tata Negara (Siyasah) IAIN Langsa

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.32505/politica.v13i1.15704

Abstract

Article 5 of Indonesia’s Electronic Information and Transactions Law recognizes electronic evidence as legally valid. However, civil procedure, which still relies on the Herzien Inlandsch Reglement/Rechtreglement voor de Buitengewesten (HIR/RBg), lacks procedural standards to ensure the integrity of electronic evidence. Unlike criminal proceedings supported by investigators and forensic laboratories, civil litigants independently collect, store, and submit electronic evidence, creating risks of manipulation and inconsistent judicial assessment. This study examines the normative gap concerning the chain of custody of electronic evidence and proposes ISO/IEC 27037:2012 as a framework for judicial evaluation. Employing normative juridical research with statutory, conceptual, comparative, and case approaches, the study analyzes Decision No. 258/Pdt.G/2023/PN Blb, supported by Constitutional Court Decision No. 20/PUU-XIV/2016 as its doctrinal foundation. The findings reveal that the court assessed WhatsApp screenshots using the doctrine applicable to documentary photocopies rather than Articles 5 and 6 of the ITE Law, admitting even photocopies of photocopies without examining the original electronic data. The absence of acquisition and preservation standards leaves the evidentiary value of electronic evidence dependent on judicial discretion, creating the potential for inconsistent decisions. To address this deficiency, the study proposes a three-pillar framework: imposing a bewijsvoering obligation on the submitting party, adopting the four stages and four principles of ISO/IEC 27037:2012 as judicial assessment criteria, and strengthening the role of accredited digital forensic experts. Consistent with Federal Rules of Evidence Rules 902(13)–902(14) and the doctrine of spoliation of evidence, this framework can be implemented through a Supreme Court Regulation, shifting judicial assessment from evaluating only electronic content to examining the integrity of evidence acquisition, preservation, and authentication.
LEGAL ANALYSIS OF CHILD ADOPTION IN INDONESIAN CIVIL LAW BASED ON CHILD PROTECTION LAW Harriani Bianca Daryana; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), June 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56371/jirpl.v7i3.693

Abstract

Adoption is not merely an administrative act; it has far-reaching impacts on a person’s civil status and legal relationships. The primary focus of this research is to examine the procedures and requirements for adoption under Indonesian civil law, particularly within the framework of child protection regulations, and to examine the legal position and civil rights of adopted children following a court ruling, particularly regarding guardianship and inheritance rights. The research was conducted using a normative juridical approach. The data used were secondary, encompassing primary, secondary, and tertiary legal sources, and were then analyzed qualitatively. The analysis of court decisions, implementing regulations, and legal literature indicates that the adoption mechanism under Indonesian positive law must go through litigation through a court ruling. Based on Article 39 of the Child Protection Law and relevant jurisprudential precedent, this judicial process formally aims to provide legal certainty and close the gap for child trafficking practices. In addition, the regulation mandates the state to conduct oversight through measurable material and social verification to ensure the principle of “the best interests of the child” is met. From a legal perspective, the court’s decision transfers full guardianship rights to the adoptive parents, but does not sever the blood relationship (nasab) with the biological parents. Because guardianship is completely transferred, questions arise regarding the economic rights of adopted children at the time of inheritance. According to applicable law, adopted children do not automatically become heirs in abintestato; protection of their economic rights is guaranteed through alternative instruments, such as mandatory wills under Islamic law or gifts and wills under civil law. Thus, these rights can still be fulfilled as a form of welfare and social justice for adopted children.
ANALYSIS OF DISPARITY IN JURISPRUDENCE OF SUPREME COURT DECISIONS REGARDING ARTICLE 26 INCOME TAX RATE FOR PKP2B HOLDERS Agus Susetyo; Appe Hutauruk; Hotman Sinambela; Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean
JILPR Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review Vol. 7 No. 3 (2026): Journal Indonesia Law and Policy Review (JILPR), June 2026
Publisher : International Peneliti Ekonomi, Sosial dan Teknologi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.56371/jirpl.v7i3.695

Abstract

This study aims to analyze the pattern of conflict or inconsistency in the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence regarding the determination of Article 26 Income Tax (PPh) rates for holders of Coal Mining Business Work Agreements (PKP2B). The main focus of this study is to collect forms of disparity in legal considerations (decision ratios) of Supreme Court judges in deciding Judicial Review (PK) cases that are released on conflicts of contract law regimes, domestic tax law, and international law. The research method used is normative legal research (normative juridical) using a statutory regulatory approach (statutory approach), a case approach (case approach), a contextual approach (conceptual approach), and a comparative approach (comparative approach). Data were collected through a literature review method to trace primary legal materials in the form of court decisions and laws, as well as secondary and tertiary legal materials, which were then analyzed qualitatively with deductive reasoning. The results of the study indicate that the pattern of jurisprudential disparity is divided into two opposing tendencies: first, a contractual approach that prioritizes the principle of lex specialis derogat legi generali to protect fiscal stabilization clauses in PKP2B; and second, a public law approach based on the principle of lex posterior derogat legi priori which emphasizes that tax law is coercive. This disparity is further complicated by considerations based on the principle of pacta sunt servanda which prioritizes the supremacy of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (P3B). This study concludes that the clash of legal paradigms, coupled with the less-than-optimal nomophilia function of the Supreme Court, has created legal activists who have the potential to undermine global investor confidence and prolong horizontal tax conflicts. Comprehensive harmonization of the intersection of norms governing this strategic sector is urgently needed.
Co-Authors Abdul Gofur Abizar Algifari Adalin Ali Adalin Ali Adalin Ali, Ade Rifa Salsabilla Adi Saputro Adi Suseno Aditya Dwi Laksono Aditya Dwi Prasetyo Adzim Munawali Afriandi Azhar Agung Prasetyo Agus Setiyawan Agus Susetyo Ahmad Sirojuddin Ahsan Pasinringi Akhmad Dinul Kholis Akhmad Ramadhan Harahap Almira Dinda Kartika Alponsus Simbolon Amin Saleh Ananda, Selvira Paulina Andri Dedi Kurniawan Andri Kurnia Anwar Arief Prayoga Arief Widodo Aswin Suwardi Ayahandono Kussetyadi Bahori Ahoen Bahori Ahoen Bahtiar Baihaqi Ramadhan Benny Wijaya Biochandra Hutapea Boy Three Immanuel Hutasoit Buhit Christian Caesar Daffa Nugraha Cahyo Priyono Cliff Fabian Maliangkay Daniel Mari Hot Nababan Darmawan Tjaputra David Yuwono Dede Ardiansyah Dedi Saputra Denny Cahyadi Tiono Denny Ramadhan Dimas Arifianto Suryo Ebit Kartono Mandala Putra Edmon Derson Simamora Edy Susanto Eko Dwi Suryanto Eko Fauzi Eko Wahyu Pramono Eko Wahyu Pramono Erwin Hutasoit Eti Kusharyanti Faizal Faizal Faizal Imam Muharam Fakhry Rozi Mujoko Fauzi Fauzi Jamal Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaea Fendi Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean Fendy Hutahaean Filemon Gunawan Dirjanto Fitriana Sari Franky Bangkit Sumardi Fredy Penmaley Frency Samuel S S FX Suyud Margon FX Suyud Margono FX Suyud Margono Gabriel Libertus Turnip Gersong Fernando Getta Mutiasari Gunawan Hadi Nugroho Gusthi Satya Kurniawan Hapit Sugandi Harriani Bianca Daryana Hendry Maxi Kewas Hera Widjayanti Herlambang Herlambang Hermawan Wibisono Putra Heru Mario Hesty C Simatupang Hotman Sinambe Hotman Sinambela Hotman Sinambela Hotman Sinambela Hotman Sinambela Hotman Sinambela Hotman Sinambela Ida Ayu Asti Manuaba Idrus Firdaus Rahmat Imam Syafii Imron Bagus Indra Bakti Saputra Indra Jaya Indra Jaya Indra Jaya Indriastuti, Desy Indryani Intan Trisna Metiarni Iqba Alkholidi Irene Puteri Alfani Sinaga Istiyanda Iqbal Fatullah Ivana Barnesa Janti Saragih Jaozi Jasatua Jaya, Setia Jody Agy Napitupulu John Hendry Suryo Wibowo Jois Candra Panjaitan Jusak Budiman Soehardja Kefi Firdaus Thon Kencana Wulan Kharismawati Kiki Ridwan Lamhot Hutahaean Lebrina Wonlele Lim Sang Hong Lyia Aina Prihadiyati M. Amin Saleh Mardiman Sane Maria Prihadiyanti Martua Manik Maruba Parlindungan Hutahaean Mas Agus Priyambodo Maskur Muchamad Ariyanto Pradana Muh Amin Saleh Muh Amin Saleh Muh. Amin Saleh Muhammad Amin Saleh Al-Habsy Muhammad Arafah Muhammad Nasir Muhammad Nur Muhenri Sihotang Muhenri Sihotang Muhenri Sihotang Muslih Anhar Mutia Sakti Najwa Aulia Ramadhani Nana Kurnia Natalia Vivi Natan Dityanggoro Natan, Antonius Ngatiyono Nico Wandiredja Nurkenda Okky Mara Utama Pahala Sinambela Purwanto Budi Santoso R. Chresno Wahyu Widodo Raden Sihar Martogi Sinambela Raden Sihar Martogi Sinambela Rahmad David Djauhari Rasman Rasman Raya Gomal Manalu Relita Hafsidiany Rengga Chrisetio Sadewo Ricky Kurniawan Suriana Rifai Lumbantoruan Rinta Pratiwi Rintan Ayu Andini Rivaldo Valentino Wibowo Robert L . Simanungkalit Robert L Simanungkalit Robert L Simanungkalit Robert L. Simanungkalit Rompas, Jopie Tommy Rony Hutahaean RR Lyia Aina Prihadiati RR Lyia Aina Prihadiyanti Ruby W H Oktolina Samosir Ruby W H Oktolina Samosir Rudyanto Dahlan Rumondang Sihite Rusly Rusly Saifudin Wahid Sapto Setiaji Satrio Nugroho Selamat Rapama Sihombing Sendi Sanjaya Setia Jaya Shinta Maharani Sihotang, Muhenri Simanungkalit, Robert L Simanungkalit, Robert L. Stanisius Leo Stenly Minti Sugi Hariyanto Suharyono Suhermi Suhermi Sularto Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Sunarno Supadmi Sutan Sulaiman Sutarso Sutarso Suyud Margono Syeni Adriana Lasut Taberima, Victor Arthur Tarkam Suwirya Tatang Ruslih Taufik Maulana, Taufik Tri Heriyanto Tricia Elisabeth Napitupulu Tridianto, Ari Tumpal Haojahan Sihombing Vizarra Pingkan Huiriady Wadyansah Prasakti Nugraha Widia Wirawan Yandri Sinlaeloe Yanto Kurnia Yendrizen Yogi Fajran Qausar Yohanes Higayon Yulianto Kiswocahyono Yulianto Kiswocahyono Yulis Setyaningsih Yustian Yustian Yusuf Chornia Zul Ashari