Color additives play a crucial role in enhancing the visual quality and consumer acceptance of fish products; however, differences in stability between natural and synthetic colorants, particularly under thermal processing, remain a key concern. This study aimed to evaluate the effects of natural colorants (fresh and powdered turmeric) and synthetic colorants on the color stability and sensory acceptance of mackerel (Rastrelliger sp.) during steaming. A Completely Randomized Design (CRD) with four treatments (control, fresh turmeric 1%, turmeric powder 1%, and synthetic colorant 1%) and three replications was applied. Analyses included CIELab color parameters (L*, a*, b*), texture (hardness), and sensory evaluation using a 9-point hedonic scale covering color, aroma, taste, texture, appearance, and overall acceptance. The results showed that prior to steaming, synthetic colorants produced the highest color intensity (a* 6.80; b* 35.10), while turmeric powder performed better than fresh turmeric. After steaming, L* values increased due to protein denaturation, whereas b* values decreased across treatments, indicating pigment degradation; however, synthetic colorants exhibited the highest stability. Texture decreased significantly after steaming and was not affected by colorant type. Sensory evaluation indicated a significant improvement in acceptance after steaming, with the highest overall score in the synthetic treatment (8.31), followed by turmeric powder (7.25). In conclusion, synthetic colorants provided superior color stability and sensory acceptance, while turmeric powder represents the most effective natural alternative for improving product quality with better safety considerations.