p-Index From 2021 - 2026
8.812
P-Index
This Author published in this journals
All Journal IAES International Journal of Artificial Intelligence (IJ-AI) Pythagoras: Jurnal Matematika dan Pendidikan Matematika JURNAL SAINS PERTANIAN EQUATOR TARBIYA : Journal Education in Muslim Society Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan Matematika Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika Majalah Ilmiah Pendidikan Matematika dan Ilmu Pengetahuan Alam Jurnal Pembelajaran Berpikir Matematika Jurnal Matematika dan Statistika serta Aplikasinya (Jurnal MSA) Jurnal Sains dan Teknologi Pangan Enthalpy : Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa Teknik Mesin Jurnal Maneksi (Management Ekonomi Dan Akuntansi) BAREKENG: Jurnal Ilmu Matematika dan Terapan International Journal on Emerging Mathematics Education Al Qalam: Jurnal Ilmiah Keagamaan dan Kemasyarakatan Fair Value: Jurnal Ilmiah Akuntansi dan Keuangan JURNAL PENDIDIKAN TAMBUSAI Jurnal Basicedu Gorontalo Accounting Journal GERVASI: Jurnal Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat Jurnal Sekretari Universitas Pamulang ALGORITMA : Journal of Mathematics Education Ilomata International Journal of Tax and Accounting Jurnal Amal Pendidikan Pasundan Journal of Mathematics Education : Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika Edunomics Journal Jurnal Ekonomi Indonesia IJORER : International Journal of Recent Educational Research Dharmas Education Journal (DE_Journal) Acman: Accounting and Management Journal JEER (Journal of Elementary Educational Research) Mafaza : Jurnal Pengabdian Masyarakat Jurnal Basicedu Prosiding Seminar Nasional Official Statistics Jurnal Pepadu Pena Dimas Electronic, Business, Management and Technology Journal Tarsius: Jurnal Pengabdian Tarbiyah, Religius, Inovatif, Edukatif dan Humanis Jurnal Riset Ilmiah Indonesian Journal of Community Empowerment Jurnal Ekonomi Kependudukan dan Keluarga
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

Evaluating Hajj and Umrah Guide Certification as a Model of Da‘wah Education for Quality Assurance Abdul, Hafiz; Muhammad, Zuhdi; Kadir, Kadir; Sapiudin, Sapiudin
IJORER : International Journal of Recent Educational Research Vol. 7 No. 4 (2026): July
Publisher : Faculty of Teacher Training and Education Muhammadiyah University of Makassar

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.46245/ijorer.v7i4.1347

Abstract

Objective: This study evaluates the effectiveness of the Professional Hajj and Umrah Guide Certification Education and Training Program as a quality assurance mechanism for manasik guidance in Indonesia. The research responds to the critical need to ensure that guides possess not only administrative qualifications but also professional, pedagogical, and spiritual competencies amid the increasing complexity of Hajj management. Using a descriptive quantitative approach, data were collected from 374 program alumni through questionnaires, interviews, document analysis, and pre- and post-tests. The study applies a comprehensive evaluation framework integrating the CIPPO (Context, Input, Process, Product, Outcome) model with Kirkpatrick’s four-level evaluation (Reaction, Learning, Behavior, Result). Data analysis employed descriptive statistics, paired sample t-tests, and qualitative triangulation. Results indicate high relevance and effectiveness across all evaluation aspects. A significant improvement in participants’ competencies was confirmed by the paired sample t-test ($t = -16.853$; $p < 0.05$), despite a modest score increase due to rigorous assessment standards. Overall, the program effectively enhances the scientific, spiritual, and professional competence of certified guides and strengthens national quality assurance for Hajj and Umrah guidance services. Novelty: This study establishes a novel approach to Islamic education evaluation by successfully integrating the macro-level CIPPO framework with the micro-level Kirkpatrick model to assess professional da‘wah training. Unlike previous studies that focus purely on the administrative or theological aspects of Hajj, this research offers a new, standardized quality assurance paradigm that redefines Hajj and Umrah certification as a structured, measurable model of professional da‘wah education.
Co-Authors & La Masi A, Muhammad Tahir Aan Hardiyana Abd. Kadir Abd. Rafiun Abdul Muin Abdul, Hafiz Ady Akbar Agung Budi Santoso Ahmad Dimyati Ahmad Jazuli, La Ode Aisyah Wiyono Al Kahar, Aris Armeth Daud Andi Asma Andriani, Yayuk Anggraini Anggraini Ansharullah ansharullah Anugrah, Dinda Rahmawati Anuli, Wadan Y Anuli, Wildan Y Anwar Bey Anwar Bey Apriliani, Lina Ardianto Ardianto Arhanuddin Salim Arlando, Abraham Dwi Arsidaryani Putri Imran Arvyaty Arvyaty Arvyaty Arvyaty Arvyaty, Arvyaty Asikin, Munawar Awal, Iqbal Julmadat Awaludin . Ayu Putri Fajar Azam Syukur Rahmatullah, Azam Syukur Azhar Azhar Bachdar, Aditya Jibril Zahran Bachtiar, Ishak Gary Bagus Sumargo, Bagus Chairina Chairina, Chairina Coenraad, Dhea Perdana Darise, Gina Nurvina Dedhy Setyadi Desy Payung Allo Dini Anggorowati Dita Jeza Silondae Doni Stiadi Dwi Cahyani Dwi Fatmah Saputri Edi Cahyono Edi Cahyono Eka Murtiawan, Wayan Eka Puteri, Wa Ode Rahmaini Era Maryanti Faad Maonde Fahinu . Fahinu, Fahinu Fahmi Rizani Fajar Euis Nagara Putri Falihin, Falihin Faranita, Sitti Farida Farida Fenti Fenti Fitriyenni, Srigustia Gamsir, Gamsir Gugum Pamungkas Hadi, Amanda La Hafiludin Samparadja Hafiludin Samparadja Halaa, Giska Iswara Haris Nurdiansyah, Haris Hariyani Ode, Nining Haryanto Haryanto Hasanudin, La Hasminah . Hasnawati Hasnawati Hastri Rosiyanti Hendriani Hendriani Herawati, Teti Hilmianto, Rizky Iasha, Vina Idji, Dinda Rahmawati Anugrah Ikman Ikman Ikroma, Najmi Imam Heryanto Irman Firmansyah Irzain, La Ode Jafar Jafar Jafar Jafar Jafar Jafar Jumroidah, Siti Kadang, Abd. Wahid S Kadir Tiya Kadir, Abd . Kahar, Aris Armeth Daud Al Karyana, Sri Kodirun Komara, Anton Tirta Kurniasari, Mustika Kurniawati, Lia La Arapu La Arapu La Arapu La Arapu La Arapu La Masi La Masi La Masi La Ndia, La Ndia La Ode Ahmad Jazuli La Ode Nggawu Lafose, Maliadin Lambertus Lambertus Lamusu, Chen Aldia Latief Sahidin Latief Sahidin Lesmanawati, Yunita Limarjani, Sustinah Luh Putu Ratna Sundari M. Yogi Riyantama Isjoni Manisi, La Marudut, Masani Romauli Helena Marwa, Marwa Mellani Yuliastina Misu, La Mohamad Salam MUHAMMAD HASBI Muhammad Hudaya Muhammad Nur Holis Muhammad Sudia Muhammad Sudia Muhammad Sudia Muhammad Tahir Muhammad, Zuhdi Muhardin, Muhardin Mukhsar . Mursidin T Mursidin T, Mursidin Mustamin Anggo Mustamin Anggo Mutmainah Mutmainah Naiaki, Maria Fridolina Natsir Natsir Neni Ferli Yanti Ngurah Adhi Wibawa, Gusti Ni Kadek Sarniasih Nilam Novita Sari Ningsih, Nidia Fauziah Nordiansyah, Muhammad Novita Kumala Sari Nur Hidayah Nuraisah, Risma Nurbianti K, Nining Nurhayati Nurhayati Oktavia, Yovi Otoluwa, Moon Hidayati Prajono, Rahmad Prasetyo, Octavia Rizky Putra, Riyanda Qasim . Qulsum, Liza Novia Rahmad Prajono Rahmad Prajono Rahmat Rahmat Rahmawati, Nurlaela Rajak, Andri Ramdani Miftah Ramlin Ramlin Rasidah Rasidah, Rasidah Rasmin, Rasmin Reksamunandar, Rhyan Prayuddy RH. Fitri Faradilla Ridway Balaka, Ridway Robert Kurniawan, Robert Romlah Abubakar Askar, Romlah Abubakar Rosdiana Rosdiana Rufeidah, Annie Ruslan Ruslan Rusli Badaruddin Rusma Nailiah Saad, Sofyan Sabarudin Sabarudin Sabindo, La Ode Safari La, Safari Safari Safari, Safari Safariza, Dena Safarudin Safarudin, Safarudin Sahibe, Nurhayati Sahidin, Latief Sahidin, Latief Sahrul . Saleh Saleh Saleh Saleh, Saleh Salim Salim Salim Salim Salim Salim Salim Salim, Salim Salimin Salimin, Salimin Samhuddin Samhuddin, Samhuddin Sandri Yulia Citra Sapiudin Sariningsih, Wini Sarwani Sarwani, Sarwani Satria, Rd Okky Saud, Indah Wardaty Setiyawan, Wa Ode Nining Sigit Sugiarto Silva Dara, Liza Sima Yuningsih Siregar, Dania Siska Andriani Siska Damayanti Syukur Siti Hadijah Siti Jibaigun Siti Sarmiati Sitriani Sitriani Sitti Amaliyah Adriani Sitti Muslia Sosilawati, Maya Sri Debi Sri Wahyuni Ningsi Suardani, Ni Kadek Suhar & Suhar Suhar Suhar Suhar Suhar, Suhar Sukatin, Sukatin Suparjo, Muhamad Susanto, Weldi Syah, Ilham Syahrun, Muhammad Syaiful Hifni Syawaluddin Syawaluddin, Syawaluddin Tatiriah . Tetty Apryani Tria Oktarzi Malenda Tunggali, Harfiah Jannah Tungkagi, Calvina Izumi Putri Umbara, Danu Utu Rahim Utu Rahim Wa Ode Haliana Wa Ode Nur Isrian Sani Wa Ode Nurmila Wa Ode Sulistian Lestari Barudi Wa Sudi Wahidin Wahidin Wahyu Pratama Mahiuddin Wahyudin Nor Wardani Rahayu Wardhana, Dewi Wardini, Sri Gusti Weni Lidya Sukma Wiwik Handayani Yamin, Muhammad Nurul Yanti, Noer Rakhmat Yoppy Wahyu Purnomo YUSNITA YUSNITA Yustisiana Sari Yustiti, Yustiti Zahratusitha Timbulus, Nazwa Zainal Abidin Zainal, Nur Fitriani Zuliyati, Wa Ode