p-Index From 2021 - 2026
13.516
P-Index
This Author published in this journals
All Journal Jurnal Cerdas Sifa Pendidikan Jurnal Konseling dan Pendidikan Potensia JPsd ( Jurnal Pendidikan Sekolah Dasar ) IJLECR (International Journal of Language Education and Cultural Review) JURNAL PENDIDIKAN TEMATIK DIKDAS IDEAS: Journal on English Language Teaching and Learning, Linguistics and Literature Al Ishlah Jurnal Pendidikan Jurnal Ilmiah Universitas Batanghari Jambi Jurnal Penelitian Pendidikan IPA (JPPIPA) MODELING: Jurnal Program Studi PGMI Jurnal Bidang Pendidikan Dasar AL-ATHFAL : JURNAL PENDIDIKAN ANAK METASASTRA: Jurnal Penelitian Sastra Tarbawi : Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan Pendas : Jurnah Ilmiah Pendidikan Dasar Cetta: Jurnal Ilmu Pendidikan IRJE (Indonesian Research Journal in Education) DIKBASTRA : Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra JMKSP (Jurnal Manajemen, Kepemimpinan, dan Supervisi Pendidikan) Jurnal Ilmiah Dikdaya Literasi: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Bahasa, Sastra Indonesia dan Daerah Jurnal Gentala Pendidikan Dasar Jurnal Mantik JIIP (Jurnal Ilmiah Ilmu Pendidikan) Didaktik : Jurnal Ilmiah PGSD STKIP Subang Lingua Rima: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan dan Ilmu Sosial (JMPIS) JURNAL PENDIDIKAN DASAR FLOBAMORATA Jurnal Ilmiah Wahana Pendidikan Proceeding Biology Education Conference JURNAL ILMIAH GLOBAL EDUCATION Sibatik Journal : Jurnal Ilmiah Bidang Sosial, Ekonomi, Budaya, Teknologi, Dan Pendidikan Jurnal Disastri: Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Indonesia Pena: Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa dan Sastra Journal of Childhood Development Tadbiruna: Jurnal Manajemen Pendidikan Islam Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Holistik (JIPH) Journal of General Education and Humanities Kajian Linguistik dan Sastra Jurnal Bastra (Bahasa dan Sastra) Journal of Innovation and Research in Primary Education JURNAL TUNAS PENDIDIKAN International Journal of Learning Reformation in Elementary Education Prosiding Seminar Nasional Humaniora Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Business Innovative: Journal Of Social Science Research Priviet Social Sciences Journal Kopula: Jurnal Bahasa, Sastra, dan Pendidikan PPSDP International Journal of Education JR-ELT (Journal of Research in English Language Teaching) Indonesian Educational Administration and Leadership Journal (IDEAL) Journal of Society Counseling Jurnal Cahaya Edukasi Educational Leadership and Management Journal Jurnal Pendidikan Sains Indonesia (Indonesian Journal of Science Education)
Claim Missing Document
Check
Articles

An Aptitude-Treatment Interaction Analysis of Structured Reflective Problem-Based Learning among Pre-Service Teachers: Levelling the Playing Field Adi irawan, Turino; Nazurty, Nazurty; Effendy, Muhammad Haris; Anggereini, Evita; lestari, Putri Ayu; Maharani, Della; Agustiyara, Agustiyara
Indonesian Educational Administration and Leadership Journal (IDEAL) Vol. 8 No. 2 (2026): On Progress
Publisher : Program Studi Adminsitrasi Pendidikan Universitas Jambi

Show Abstract | Download Original | Original Source | Check in Google Scholar | DOI: 10.22437/ideal.v8i2.60283

Abstract

Problem-based learning (PBL) is a pedagogical approach that has gained significant traction in higher education, with a focus on fostering higher-order thinking skills. However, unstructured inquiry has been observed to have the unintended consequence of widening achievement gaps by placing excessive cognitive demands on students who demonstrate lower levels of academic achievement. The objective of this study was to investigate the differential treatment effects of Structured Reflective Problem-Based Learning (SR-PBL) - an instructional model integrating nine sequential problem-solving phases, explicit cognitive scaffolds, rotating inquiry roles, and iterative cyclical reflection - against conventional PBL. The research was grounded in Aptitude-Treatment Interaction (ATI) theory and Cognitive Load Theory. A non-randomised quasi-experimental pretest-posttest control group design was conducted among a sample of 113 pre-service elementary teachers (PGMI) enrolled in an undergraduate Environmental Education course (n = 85 across three SR-PBL cohorts; n = 28 in a conventional PBL control cohort). Moderation regression analysis revealed a statistically significant pretest-by-treatment interaction (b=-0.173, SE=0.070, t=-2.47, p=.015), confirming that the treatment effect was systematically moderated by baseline aptitude. However, conventional PBL yielded uniform, low-level improvements regardless of incoming ability (b=-0.029, p=.637). In contrast, SR-PBL exhibited a strong compensatory pattern (b=-0.202, p<.001), with the lowest-baseline learners (≤13/28) demonstrating the largest absolute gains (M=6.96 vs. 2.25 in control) and closing the post-test gap with top performers. Sub-skill decomposition across Facione's dimensions revealed that this compensatory leap was driven by targeted gains in inference a mean score gain of +1.68 raw points overall and +1.93 among low-baseline learners) and analysis +1.09 overall and +1.11 among low-baseline learners), domains where conventional PBL generated negligible growth (+0.07 and +0.25, respectively). The findings demonstrate that structured cyclical reflection acts as an indispensable cognitive equaliser in ill-structured inquiry learning.  
Co-Authors Ade Bayu Saputra Ade Kusmana Adi irawan, Turino Adiyadmo, Dimas Anugrah Afreni Hamidah Agustiyara Agustiyara Agustiyara, Agustiyara Aini, Nur Aizya Flora Al Adawiyah, Wiya Al Farohah, An Nayla Ali, Raden Almunawaroh Fit Laila Amir Mukminin Amirul Mukminin An Nayla Al Farohah Ananda Wiinardo, Regi Andiopenta Purba Angga warda prasakti Anggelina, Selin Edri Angraini, Difa Anissa Maysaroh Aniswaty, Maida Aniyati Antonio, Marites Del Prado arianti, rita Aripudin Aripudin Asih Nur Ismiatun Asmaryadi, Ilham ASMAYANTI, ASMAYANTI Atri Widowati Aulia Cantica Nur Elisa Aulia Lailatus Siva Bayu Prasetyo Bunga Maresya Suryaningrum Bunga Rahmi Putri Chelsia Aura Ramadhanti Demylia Lady Amara Deri Rachmad Pratama, Deri Rachmad Desti Anggraini Desti Angraini Desti Angraini Destrinelli Desy Ratna Sari Dian Puspita Sari Dila Nurzafti, Kharisma Dimas Anugrah Adiyadmo Dini Nursabila Dwi Rahariyoso, Dwi Eddy Haryanto Eddy Haryanto Eddy Haryanto Edy Haryanto Effendy, Muhammad Haris Eka - Sastrawati Eko Kuntarto Eli Susanti Elsa Monica Simamora Enny Hidajati Evita Anggereini Evita Anggereini Fajar Agustian Fajar, Fajar Prasetiawan Febriani, Sandra Tri Feerlie Moonthana Indhra Fendy Ari Budiyanto Fitri, Salsabila Fortunasari, Fortunasari G. Gunawan Gita Jessica Margaretha GITA PRATIWI Gusti Haryani Hadiyanto Hadiyanto Hady Wijaya Harnita Risnawati Hary Soedarto Harjono Helty, Helty Hendra Sofyan Hendri Priyatno Hendri, M Hendriani, Hendriani Huda Huda Idha Nur Hayati Ifliadi, Ilham Ihsan Syah Putra Indra Bangsawan Indryani Indryani Indryani Indryani, Indryani Irma Suryani Irma Suryani Irsanti, Kurnia Izzati Khairina Jannah, Hidayatul Julia, Ranti Keisya Amalia Nabila Khairina, Izzati Khoirun Najwa Awalia Kirana, Dewi Kusuma, Indah Mauli Leola, Sherly Lestari, Rigina Dwi Indah Levina Putri, Sindy Liza Septa Wilyanti Lusi Dwi Anggraini Maharani, Annisa Maharani, Della Maizar Karim Maizar Karim Mar Atun Saadah Marietta Sigalingging Marsayla Pardilla Marzul Hidayat Mastikawati, Mastikawati Masyunita Siregar Maysarah Meri Rasti Moh. Indra Bangsawan Mohamad Muspawi Mohd. Norma Sampoerno Moonthana Indhra, Feerlie Muarif, Miftahul Muazza Muazza Muazzomi, Nyimas Muhammad Afif Hibatullah Muhammad Haris Effendi Hasibuan Muhammad Haris Effendi Hasibuan Muhammad Sofwan Mukhlash Abrar Nada Sawita Nadia Oktaviani Asmi Nadya Aprilia Naifa Mardati Nanda Gusfira Natasya Aulia Putri Netty Hasanah Nia Daniati Nia Raudhatul Aulya Nikita Adewina Nofrita, Misra Nova Ardianti Noviyanti, Silvina Nuratikah Najua Pauzi Nurfadilah Nurfadilah Nurfadilah Nurfitri Susanti Nurjannah Nurjannah Nurmina Nurmina, Nurmina Nurul Huda Azkia Oki Surhadi Oki Surhadi Oktania Oktania Oktavia, Gessy Frischa Oktaviani, Sengky PALMIZAL A Purwati, Septi Puti Masurai Putimasurai Putimasurai Putimasurai Putri Ayu Lestari Putri Ayu Lestari Putri Dini Rawati Putri Lestari Rahman, Fadhilla RAMADHANI, AULYA Ratih Aulia Rahma Ratna Wulandari Raudahtul Feby Diani Renny Pita Rahmadani Ridwan Ridwan Rina Tupon Pangudi Luhur Rinda Ririn Anggraini Ririn Meylani Riris Marisi Rosinda Simarmata Rita Tarmika Romundza, Febbry Rosmiati Rosmiati Roudotul Janna Rustam Rustam Rustam Rut Putri Raja Gukguk Sampoerno, Mohd. Norma Sandra Tri Febriani Sania Saputra, Ade Bayu Saputri, Pratiwi Sawita, Nada Sean Popo Hardi Selfi Puspita Sari Shobrina Fitri Sholeha, Puji Silvina Noviyanti Silvina Noviyanti Simarmata, Riris Marisi Rosinda Simatupang, Kristin Friskila Siregar, Pariang Sonang Siti Enik Mukhoiyaroh Bambang Siti Fitriah Siti Mariah Ulfa Situmeang, Hizkia Mustika Ida Sophia Rahmawati Suci Okta Piyana Sudaryono Sudaryono Sukendro Sukendro Sukendro Sukendro SUKENDRO SUKENDRO, SUKENDRO Sulistiyo, Urip Sulistyo, Urip Syahrial, Syahrial Syifa, Putri T., Friscillawulan Tito Anggara, Reza Trisna Trisna, Trisna Turino Adi Irawan Tya Ramadhani Ulfa Fitri Fazhira Umi Kalsum Viska Agima putri Vita Amalia Wahyu Yovika Hermawanti Warni Warni Warni Warni Widia Gustiani Widiyasih, Maharani Wita Septyadi Yantoro, Yantoro Yasir Riady Yulianti Dara Putri Yumni Alifa, Nazhira Yundi Fitrah Yundi Fitrah, Yundi Fitrah Yunita Febrianti Yunita, Henny Yusra D. Yuyun Arofah Zainal Rafli, Zainal Zalviardi, Sanca Zulfia, Dinda Pebri Zusniarni Zusniarni Zusniarni, Zusniarni